
|
|
|
 |
|
The
dress and instruments of a Tay shaman |
|
The Thaan
PERFORMER OF THE DAI AS FOLK SINGER AND SHAMAN
Among folk cultural survivals of Tay
ethnic groups in the northeastern & northwestern parts
of Vietnam, thaan is a religious folk song which is
performed with music and dance.Thaan is not only sung
for entertainment and amusement but also for religious
and spiritual purposes on different ritual occasions.
Thaan is spread widely among the Dai* dwelling in the
provices of Lang Son, Cao Bang, Tuyen Quang,
BacThai,and Ha Giang and Laocai. This article is part of
the result of my fieldwork in summer of 1997, and a
recent trip we made together with Bangkok Friend of
Museum to North West region of Vietnam when I went to
see a few of thaan performers. I interviewed them,
observed and made photos of a number of performances
among the Daic in Hoa An district, Cao Bang province
and at Trung Do village, Cocly Commune, Bac Ha
district, Lao Cai province. In this article, I will
offer preliminary on the thaan performer as a folk
singer and as a shaman and classify thaan performers
according to professional characteristics.
|
|
In the
Dai tradition, when a family has misfortune or one of
its members falls ill , they invite a thaan performer to
carry out ritual ceremonies as a folk singer who brings
cheer and warms up the household, and as a shaman who
can intercede within visible spirits and asks them for
help to save someone from bad luck and heals patients
spiritually by calling their life-souls back to the
body. According to the cosmology of the Dai and other
ethnic groups in Asia, life-souls are centered in the
body. Sickness and disease are explained by the loss and
separation of one or more of these souls from the body.
The thaan performer, therefore, is not only singing
songs but also performing the rites of soul-calling to
bodies, bring peaceful life to household and restore
health to the community members.
The
performance of thaan is a journey of its practitioner,
who is believed to be in a trance, to contact invisible
worlds to intercede with spirits and fulfill his task as
a shaman, ceremony master and folk singer entertaining
his people. During his journey, the performer and his
recruited attendants gather horses, and prepare spare
food to enter realms of ancestors, spirits of land,
mountains, agriculture, and gods to ask for spiritual
assistance. The shamanistic thaan singers can be defined
as a family and community of traditions whose
practitioners focus on entering alternate states of
consciousness (Walsh 1990:11).The thaan performers are
not mere folk singers, though many other scholars (Duong
Kim Boi 1978, Hoa Cuong 1993, and Nong Van Hoan1978)have
maintained that. By means of observation and interviews
with the performers and the audience, I have discovered
that they are characterized by the so-called ''technique
of ecstasy''(Eliade1964) and the ''journey'' to
non-human realms(Walsh1992) as is typical for shamans.
By discussing the religious features of thaan, I will
demonstrate the shamanistic nature and the essence of
the ritual, as well as its practitioners as folk singers
and shamans.
Thaan
religiosity encompasses a blend of the popular Dai
religion and religion and shamanism. While practicing,
the thaan performers sing songs, pray for help to
animated spirits, and enter into trance, a state
characteristic of shamans. The performers who enter into
that state of semi-consciousness for the first time go
through the ''initiation crisis''. This occurs when the
thaan ancestor spirits bestow upon them the skills and
training for the vocation. They cannot refuse such
skills and must accept this opportunity as a destiny
prescribed by supernatural powers.
In
Vietnam, we can observe several types of religious
ritual practitioners who are identified as mediums
orshamans and can communicate with invisible spirits.
The ''thay cung'' give offerings and performances all
over the country. They work for private families and
perform other community ceremonies too. They can also
solve problems for the individual who'' wishes to
contact the world beyond and understand the reasons for
sickness and distress'' in'' dealing with the various
events of life (birth, illness, accidents,
miscarriages),etc'' (Bertrand 1996:270-1). Among the
indigenous practices of the Viet, for example, the hau
băng is a central ceremony in which spirits of the dao
tu phu (four palace religion[vn]) possess mediums called
ba dong (a female medium),or ong dong (a male
medium).These mediums are believed to be able to call
spiritual entities into their body in a mediumistic
state to serve their communiry on demand for religious
needs. They are ''the specialists in spirit possession.
Whle they do not journey, they do enter altered states
in which they experience themselves as receiving
messages from the spirit world'' (Walsh1990:16).
Unlike
the hau bong, the thaan practitioners experience an
ecstasy which is a state of ''journeying, the practice
that is one of the defining characteristics of
shamanism''
(Walsh1990:17) . The thaan shamans experience journeying
or ''out of body experiences'',''traveling to other
realms at will, and interacting with other entities in
order to serve his community''(Walsh1990:11). When the
thaan practitioners enter onto a trance, they interact
with Ngoc Hoang( the god of heaven, the jade Emperor) or
Long Vuong (the water dragon king), as well as other
spirits living within the house or in the locality. The
shamans can also have contact with ancestors, spirits
of deceased people, and spirits of animated cosmic
surroundings on their journey to the invisible worlds.
In this sense, the thaan ritual of the Dai is a very
synthetic type of religious practice, which is defined
by the offering ceremony of a thay cung ,the experience
of trance and the journey of a shaman, and the song of a
folk singer. Thaan performers play many roles, both
sacred and profane. They are spiritual healers, singers,
and keepers of cultural traditions and customs. Using
their bestowed supernatural power, the thaan shamans
can address not only individual problem but also
problems experienced by the whole community:
Being
given a task from god,
the thaan performers have magical power.
They save people all over the country
With prayers and smell of flying incense to the
three worlds,
They govern the whole country and fight against evil
spirits.
The thaan
performers venerate their family ancestors and their
vocation's spirits. Besides the ancestors' altar, they
have another altar for worshipping buddhist and Taoist
images, as well as other supernatural images including
the thaan's spirit, called taan. Taan enters into a
layperson's body in order to force him or her to
practice thaan rituals. Later on, when he or she has
become a destined thaan performer, sometimes, thaan
khaak(the male thaan spirit) possesses the female thaan
performer os as to court a lua naang, a female thaan's
friend. The thaan khaak drinks wine with the lua naang
and they sing together and tease each other. The other
kind of male thaan spirit is taan luk hiu who enters a
female thaan body to be the husband of a lua naang.They
are spiritually married and live together in spirit
worlds. There are other spirits that enter into the
thaan practitioners such as the female and male water
spirits called thuang, who assist the thaan shamans when
they cross the ocean to the heaven called Ngoc Hoang (La
Van Lo,Ha Van Thu1984:30).
Not every
Daic is able to perform thaan at a ritual ceremony. Some
common Daic people can sing the thaan folk songs by
memorizing performances by destined shamans, but only
people who'' profess to maintain relations with spirits'
'' (Eliade 1964:5)can perform the rite of thaan singing;
they are ''of the elected' and as such they have access
to a region of the sacred inaccessible to other
members'' and ''they are separated from the rest of the
community'' (Eliade 1964:7-8).The songs of destined
thaan practitioners are thought to have never
disappeared. Their songs are transmitted to the new
appointed practitioners . After death, the thaan masters
become the vocation's ancestors and return to their
chosen community members in the latter's dreams to teach
the songs. The thaan spirit guides will assist the new
performers in their ceremonies.
The thaan performers differ in their location and their
use of musical instruments. Most thaan singers are Dai;
only a few of them are Nung, Viet, and Hmong. The thaan
performers in western Cao Bang and Lang Son provinces
are female. In eastern Cao Bang the Bac Son district of
Lang Son province, and in some villages of Bac Thai and
Tuyen Quang provinces. The thaan in Trung Do village,
Loacai province is also a female. Alarge number of
singers are male and are called zaang or chaang(Nong Van
Hoan 1992:14). The thaan in Trung Do village is also
female. In the Dai language, thaan performers are
called thaan "put" and chaang,who are distinguished from
one another by gender, musical instruments used, and
melodies sung .
In Cao Bang province, the general
name of a female thaan perfomer is put ,e,g: put Lang,
put Uc, or put Yen. They are also called put ting
because while singing they play the ting. In eastern
Cao Bang, the male thaan singer is called chaang. During
the performance, he wears female clothing including pink
dresses, hats, and waist ribbons. The reason that chaang
has to disguise as female is the meaning of thaan for
the female charming spirit . Sometime, thaan and put are
distinguished by the fact that the thaan singer plays
both ting and sok( a rattle or shaker ) whereas a put
who plays only the sok is called put ngaan in some
places. In some villages, the singer plays only a "quat"
in performance, so this performer is called thaan quat.
It is popular in Yen Minh district, Ha Giang province.
The following are categories of the thaan performers.
Because of the holy thaan vocation
and of influences of several religions, thaan performers
have to follow a strict set of rules. In the house where
a family member practices thaan, there is always an
altar devoted to the thaan's ancestor in the most solemn
place right in the middle room. It is placed on the
center of the wall even higher than the family's
ancestors. The altar is decorated and covered with
brocade or laudatory writings, as well as images and
prints representing the Buddha. Before starting a
performance, the shamans light incense on the altar.
This begins the ceremony in order to call their thaan's
ancestors and helping spirits. The intention is to get
every benevolent spirit involved in the ceremony. On
the altar of the thaan's ancestor, the decoration is
intricate, with colorful paper images representing
swallows, which symbolic market place in heaven.
Under the rules of the religion ,the
thaan performers have to abstain from touching unclean
things such as animal dung, and eating beef and water
buffalo meat, which for them are fetid. If members
living in the same house as performers happen to consume
some beef or buffalo meat, they will be sent out of the
house until the following day. Otherwise they bring an
unclean smell into the house and might punish them. The
punishments can range from uncontrolled dancing to
insanity, and the singers who have committed or insane.
The following is a story about the
spirit's punishment of one such performer i heard from
an informant. Ma Van An in Doc Lap commune, Quang Hoa
distrct, Cao Bang province told me that in his village a
female thaan singer named Nong Thi Njung went to town to
live with her husband. She stopped performing thaan
and began to eat beef and buffalo meat, so she was
punished by her helping spirit and became mentally ill.
Then, when she came back to her village to continue as a
thaan performer, she recovered from her mental state and
began to be normal. After a certain time she left the
village for the town and ate the forbidden food again.
She was punished harshly for breaking the taboo: one day
she wandered around madly and jumped into a river and
died. The person who told this story emphasized that
Nong Thi Njung's destiny was obilgatory; she had to be
free of the spirit's will. Therefore, she received a
fatal punishment.
The thaan practitioners have other
taboos which, if transgressed against, involve a serious
violation. The guilty parties are punished by the thaan
ancestors. As a result, they are forbidden to enter the
thaan vocation. Ly Thi Hoa in Doc Lap commune could no
longer practice thaan at the age of 71. She used to be a
well-known performer in the region and had many
invitations from her villagers. To get a higher
position in the thaan vocation, she organized the third
ceremony of lau put. During the rite,however she
violated a rule. On atable, twelve bowls of different
kinds of food and other things were placed. The bowls
were covered by cloth. According to the rules, she had
to pick up a bowl at random and eat whatever was in it.
She refused to eat the chosen food because it was awful.
Afterward her thaan singing ability was lost, as well as
her power and popular reputation, and her respect. She
could not practice thaan anymore. When I went to see her
in the middle of the seventh month festival in1997, she
sang and practiced a performance on that day in front of
the thaan ancestor's altar at her house, from the first
cock crow until midnight of the following day. She
looked sad and weak, like a very sick person. When I
asked her about her vocation as a thaan practitioner,
she did not want to talk. Maybe she didn't want to
remember her violation. Unlike other thaan singers, who
can sing in the state of ecstasy without a ritual
ceremony, put Hoa does not sing any songs. She confesses
that she does not remember any words on her own; only in
ritual ceremonies , after she calls helping to return
and guide her, can she sing the songs. Put Dien in Ha
Quang or put Binh in the town of Cao Bang can sing
without the real ritual ceremonies.
What they need for singing without a ceremony is to
light some incense in order to get permission from their
thaan ancestors.
During a long performance, the thaan practitioners
communicate with participants in a state of ecstasy.
They speak, but do not fully understand and remember
after returning to consciousness. While performing, no
one is allowed to touch the practitioners, especially
when they shake the rattle, for symbolically, at that
moment, they are riding a horse on the journey to the
other world .Anyone who violates the taboo fills down
from the horse and is hurt or gets sick.
The performers differ in the
spiritual nature of their vocation. Depending on the
sacredness and secularity of the thaan vocation, we can
classify the thaan performers into two
groups:(1)successors,(2)put dip.
1. successors are appointed by deceased masters who are
also called the 'hereditary transmitters of their family
and community vocation. This tradition is passed down
from generation to generation .When the than singers
pass away, they transmit their vocation to someone in
their family or to a community member. The selected
persons are supposedly ninh mau (people with light souls
[vn]). That is , spirits can easily enter their souls
and possess them. Once they are chosen as hereditary
thaan practitioners, they cannot refuse it in any way.
If they make an effort to resist, they and their family
members will have frequent misfortune. They will either
get sick or when they raise farm animals such as poultry
or livestock, these animals will perish as well. If they
try to plant crops the result will be that all the
plants will turn yellow, wither, and then die.
During my fieldwork, I went to see a
few thaan performers in Ha Quang, Hoa An,and Quang Hoa
districts, and the capital town of Cao Bang province.The
shamans and their relatives told me nearly the same
story about the power of their thaan ancestor apirits.
Their deceased ancestors (great grandmother,
grandmother, or mother) were thaan performers. After
death, they become spirits of thaan who, one day, return
to the persons who are subject to the spirits' attacks.
The chosen individuals start to nhay xuong (come down[vn]).
This expression describes the dancing movement and
action of the selected persons by the spirits. They
begin to dance madly. This means that their than
ancestors have returned from invisible worlds to enter
them, causing them to go up to a beam of their house or
a tree, or to do thing that they cannot do in a normal
state, such as climb up a cliff. After these apparently
neurotic activities, they prepare a tray of offerings to
put on altars, burn incense, and pray to spirits. Then,
they sing and dance as if they perform a ritual
ceremony, from that moment on they are seen as thaan
practitioners. The helping spirit and the thaan
ancestors return to teach them how to practice the
thaan ceremonies in their dreams and appear in them when
ever pray to them. The spirits follow them wherever
they go to perform in order to assist and guide them.
To be a professional thaan performer,
they must undergo training both with their invisible
thaan ancestors and with human thaan teachers. To
transmit the vocation , the spirits teach them in their
dreams. Eventually, the new practitioners learn by heart
the spirit's songs and master the techniques of the
performance from dreams. They still have to perfect the
techniques more and more with thaan masters in real
ritual ceremonies, so they go to their masters' hsmes to
learn, accompany them to thaan performances, and sing
with them.
The real thaan practitioners , in the
opinion of most people, know many things in estate of
ecstasy. They can predict, intercede with supernatural
powers, sing for several hours a number of songs, and
play musical instruments. They also know temporarily how
to compose rhymed verses and are capable of clever
repartee with an audience in a given situation of the
ritual ceremonies. After their novicehood and
apprenticeship, the new practitioners are able to master
the thaan ceremony: to experience trances, sing songs
and perform ritual processes. They choose an auspicious
date to organize the first ceremony of lau put (being
accepted by their mundane masters, as well as by the god
of heaven and the thaan ancestors, and later on,
requesting promotion). In the lau put rite, the biggest
among the thaan ceremonies, the practitioners invite all
villagers, their relatives, and their colleagues (other
thaan singers around the area), and a taao-a very
powerful religious master of the highest level to
conduct the rite. The religious specialists in the
ceremony sing for three successive days in the new thaan
performer's honor and to serve as witnesses in the
recognition of the new practitioners. The spirits and
the community now accept them as ''official'' thaan
singers. After three days of singing by many performers,
they are given a robe, hat, and waistband by their
masters. Then they go to a field to pray to the spirits
of the four directions, asking for permission to be the
thaan performers. Returning home, they are tested by
jumping into a fire and sitting on sharpened bamboo
spikes. If they are not injured or hurt, that means the
spirits have allowed them to be a sacred and powerful
performers who are able to intercede with the invisible
spirits, and can experience unusual and even somewhat
supernatural phenomena. Their masters, families, and
villagers acknowledge that they have become performers
who have been chosen by thaan ancestors. They kowtow to
the new practitioners and show them respect. From that
moment on, the thaan singers have the authority and
license to practice thaan themselves. They are moved to
tears because they have begun their new lives as shamans
and religious folk singers. This event is also the pride
of their families among community members, for the
singers inherit their ancestors' vocation and fulfill
the calling of the spirits. They also take an oath that
they will not commit sins such as fighting with their
parents and relatives, stealing, and being boastful.
Neither wild they murder or even kill animals.
Hatbands mark the hierarchy of the
thaan practitioners. After the initiation ceremony, the
thaan performers wear hats with five strpes. Later on
,after each lau put rite, they add two more
hatbands,that is from five, to seven, to nine and
eventually to fifteen, the highest number possible, only
the thaan performers who are wealthy and are supported
by their families, relatives, and friends can afford all
these lau put ceremonies. In some districts of Cao Bang,
the hatbands of the thaan practitioners are not the
same. At the first initiation ceremony, practitioners
are given hats with one hatband, and every other lauput
ceremony, they add one more hatband to their hats. Thus,
by looking at their hats we can recognize the number of
their lau put rites, know their thaan performing
experiences, and their status among the destined
shamans.
2. put dip are people who love to sing thaan. They are
the thaan performers of their own free will and are
self-made.They sing the thaan songs merely for pleasure
and entertainment, and they usually accompany thaan
masters to their performances to sing with them. They
try to learn the traditional techniques of the thaan
performances but can not enter trance. They are not
given the power to intercede with spirits, and thaan's
ancestors do not grant them the status of thaan
practitioners. They cannot master the thaan ceremonies
themselves and neither are they invited to perform the
ritual by their community members.
Many people try to learn how to sing
and perform thaan but not every learner becomes the
thaan performer. Some performers are well known for a
certain time but then lose their popularity. They then
perform a ceremony in order to return to their masters
and ask to train with them again. Whenever the new
performers become masters, they are surrounded with con
so or con huong or con hoa (young students). Con huong
are sent by their parents to study under the thaan
masters' patronage. These young students follow their
masters to the ceremonies, help them to prepare the
offerings,and learn how to sin and perform a thaan
ceremony. Some of them sing for pleasure, but they stop
accompanying their thaan masters when they get married.
The other ones are called by the thaan ancestors to the
vocation and can experience trance during the
performance. They separate from their masters when they
are able to master the traditional performing techniques
.Thaan masters have many adopted children whose disease
they heal or whom they save from bad luck. On special
occasions ,on the lau put rites and on New Year's day,
these children bring gifts to their masters as a sign of
their gratitude. For instance, put Dien, a female
practitioner in the district of Ha Quang province of Cao
Bang performed the ceremony for her 48th adopted child,
which I observed in summer of 1997 .There are many pople
who practice the thaan ritual. According to statistics
kept by the Culture and Information Department of the
autonomous region of Viet Bac before 1976, the a large
number of thaan performers in a village is five (Nong
Van Hoan 1978 :13). The fact is that villagers choose
one among a large number of singers to practice thaan
for them. The life and prosperity of households are
thought to depend on the reputation and power of
performers. Their voice and their behavior as
individuals are judged by the masses during performances
and afterwards .During a performance, if they lose their
voice, forget the songs, cannot make the tradition fit
the real ceremony , or cannot answer the audience's
questions, they will be judged inadequate and could lose
their reputation. As shamans, the thaan practitioners
sometimes entertain people (La Van Lo,Ha Van Thu
1984:30).Through them, their villagers want to have
contact with invisible spirits. They hold a khaai bjook
(selling of flowers)to tian (female charming spirits) so
that the lay people have a chance to meet the spirits,
sing, and dance with them. They also have the linaan
(playing with swallows) performance in which swallows
take the lay people's souls to visit paradise in the
moon or heaven. The other kind of the entertainment
performances is dee lau (offeing of wine),w here the
deceased souls make offerings to the gd of heaven after
a trip of hardship through deep rives, high mountains,
places full of evils, and demons in order to reach
heaven. Also,girls who are not successful in love and
marriage can make friends with heavenly people, or even
get married in heaven, and men can take time to spend
with tian for a while with the help of the thaan
practitioners.
Thaan performing is a vocation given by spirits but it
is also a job for practitioners to earn a living by.
People do not like the singers who ask for too much
money and offerings as payment for their performances.
They are more respected if they do not demand a fee and
are satisfied with any payment. However, households
usually pay them according to the common rate. Put Dien
whom I met during my stay in Ha Quang was busy with
invitations because of her easy-going character, and was
very happy with what the households gave her just as a
symbol of their gratitude to her singing and practicing.
By contrast, put Nau, who lives near put Dien ,was
rarely invited to perform because she demanded high
payments. Generally, households pay a part of the
offerings, including one chicken, one duck, a section of
pork head, seven bowls of rice, and from100,000
to120,000Vietnamese dong (around 8-10US S ) in1997, and
treat the performers to several lavish meals during
their performances.
In summary, the thaan performers are
judged critically by the thaan's ancestors as vocation's
successors, talentsd folk singers and capable of
entering into trance to interact with invisible
spirits.They must be creative enough to make the
tradition fit the audience and to satisfy their
religious needs and their desire for pleasure. They sing
the thaan songs in rhymed verses in different moods
depending on the purpose of the ceremonies. The thaan
singers must have good voice, play musical instruments
well, and have a mild mannered and easy-going
character.
Note: Thaan = the spirit of shaman
|
|
|
|
|
 |